dbTalk Databases Forums  

SQL vs Access questions

comp.databases comp.databases


Discuss SQL vs Access questions in the comp.databases forum.



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old   
Forestfish
 
Posts: n/a

Default SQL vs Access questions - 08-05-2003 , 12:43 AM






Hello.
My company is planning on setting up a database for its operations.
However, the database itself will not be accessed very often. It will
sit on a Dual PIII-1.2ghz box with 1024MB RAM, and of course some nice
SCSI HDs.
The databases will grow quite large, as they will be a centralized
store of all company transactions such as gift certificates,
purchases, etc. There are only roughly 30 locations in all, and remote
updates to it will be somewhat infrequent. Queries will be even less
frequent and extremely simple in logic.

So my question is, must I really suggest that we go the extremely
expensive route of Microsoft SQL? *nix SQL or other brands of it in
general wont really work, as this company has a bad habit of choosing
MS only products.

Would Access databases be sufficient for this sort of load? Because
despite the infrequency of database accesses (maybe 100 between
updates/queries a day average), they will grow quite large in time.

Anyway, thanks for any input

Chuck

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old   
Thomas Kellerer
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: SQL vs Access questions - 08-06-2003 , 01:43 AM








Forestfish schrieb:
Quote:
Hello.
My company is planning on setting up a database for its operations.
However, the database itself will not be accessed very often. It will
sit on a Dual PIII-1.2ghz box with 1024MB RAM, and of course some nice
SCSI HDs.
The databases will grow quite large, as they will be a centralized
store of all company transactions such as gift certificates,
purchases, etc. There are only roughly 30 locations in all, and remote
updates to it will be somewhat infrequent. Queries will be even less
frequent and extremely simple in logic.

So my question is, must I really suggest that we go the extremely
expensive route of Microsoft SQL? *nix SQL or other brands of it in
general wont really work, as this company has a bad habit of choosing
MS only products.

Would Access databases be sufficient for this sort of load? Because
despite the infrequency of database accesses (maybe 100 between
updates/queries a day average), they will grow quite large in time.

Anyway, thanks for any input

Chuck
If you have the chance to influence the decision on the OS, I'd go for
Linux/PostgreSQL. Very reliable combination and not expensive at all. You a
small amount for the Linux distribution and nothing for the PostgreSQL database.

If you are concerned about support, there are comapnies giving professional
support for PostgreSQL.

MSDE might be an option (as Neb suggested), I haven't really used it with more
then one user, but basically I'm kinda reluctant towards using MS SQL (personal
opinion!)

You might consider using MySQL as well. After all a lot of large and heavily
used databases are implemented in MySQL. But look closely at the features, there
are some of the "normal" RDBMS features that MySQL lacks (or will get in a later
release). But from your description it seems that it might be sufficient.

I don't know what your programming environment is, but one of the free Java
databases like HSQLDB might be an option as well (though I'm not sure how it
will perform in a 24/7 environment)

Regards
Thomas




Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old   
Heikki Tuuri
 
Posts: n/a

Default Re: SQL vs Access questions - 08-07-2003 , 06:06 PM



Hi!

"Bob Hairgrove" <rhairgroveREMOVE (AT) THISbigfoot (DOT) com> kirjoitti viestissä
news:3f315ca1.1924887 (AT) news (DOT) webshuttle.ch...
Quote:
On 4 Aug 2003 22:43:29 -0700, mortrek (AT) yahoo (DOT) com (Forestfish) wrote:
....
well. OTOH, MySQL is great for running a read-only-access DB on a web
server, it won't offer you the transactional stability that some of
the bigger RDBMS do.
MySQL has supported transactions for 3 years now.

Quote:
Although SQL Server on a good NT system might be
all you need, my gut feeling is to stay away from Microsoft products if you
can help it (remember the Slammer?)

--
Bob Hairgrove
Best regards,

Heikki Tuuri
Innobase Oy
http://www.innodb.com
Transactions, foreign keys, and a hot backup tool for MySQL




Reply With Quote
Reply




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.