![]() | |
![]() |
| | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
#11
| |||
| |||
|
|
DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: InDeep wrote: I'm not enraged, just baffled beyond belief that nobody else has even commented or tried to get this fixed. Not intending to be the gadfly but I think rather obviously because is of so little interest no one really much cares. Making something available only to the existing customer base ("enter your IBM ID") is not the way to expand marketshare. This becomes even more poignant when one considers that the primary competitor allows anyone to download theirs for free. No ID required, no marketing questions, no hassles. Well maybe. But according to the license agreement for the down loaded Oracle server, it can only be used to create an initial single prototype of any application. It can not be used for any other purposes. That includes learning about the product, teaching the product to anyone else, patching any prototype, etc. To quote the license agreement that Oracle uses for their download... "LICENSE RIGHTS We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the program only for the purpose of developing a single prototype of your application, and not for any other purpose." Looks like you can't even use the downloaded engine to learn about the engine without breaking the license that was agreed to. Seems rather restrictive to me. XE is available for free and can be put to use commercially if one wishes. And the prototype to which you refer is a user defined prototype. You might choose, if you wish, to prototype eBay or Amazon.com. Well - not totally true. The OTN Developer License Terms for Oracle Database Express Edition states.. "Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms." and the above quote is from that document. So the way the license is worded, the XE License is more restrictive than the enterprise license because it states that all of the restrictions of the enterprise down load apply to the XE as well. Also not true about the prototype. By wording it to state "single prototype of an application" that means that it does not apply to a system, only to an application. Also, it is only allowable to be used by a single prototype, which legally means that no refinements of the prototype is allowed. That is substantially different from limiting the download to only your current customer base. Again not true. You do not have to be a customer to download. You do have to register, but you do not have to be a customer. |
#12
| |||
| |||
|
|
It is curious that Informix can be thought of as a peer with Oracle yet, I see no market buzz in the Linux world for Informix like you do for Oracle. In fact, Oracle basically took the Linux market away from anything IBM, and has even tried to say that they were first on Linux, which they clearly were not. What _is_ possible from a marketing perspective for Informix is a huge opportunity that has basically gone wasted. It's almost criminally negligent, but forgivable knowing the retards running the Marketing Dept for Informix. Kind of easy to look the other way when you understand that the product suffers from its own family more than the neighbors. |
#13
| |||
| |||
|
|
Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: InDeep wrote: I'm not enraged, just baffled beyond belief that nobody else has even commented or tried to get this fixed. Not intending to be the gadfly but I think rather obviously because is of so little interest no one really much cares. Making something available only to the existing customer base ("enter your IBM ID") is not the way to expand marketshare. This becomes even more poignant when one considers that the primary competitor allows anyone to download theirs for free. No ID required, no marketing questions, no hassles. Well maybe. But according to the license agreement for the down loaded Oracle server, it can only be used to create an initial single prototype of any application. It can not be used for any other purposes. That includes learning about the product, teaching the product to anyone else, patching any prototype, etc. To quote the license agreement that Oracle uses for their download... "LICENSE RIGHTS We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the program only for the purpose of developing a single prototype of your application, and not for any other purpose." Looks like you can't even use the downloaded engine to learn about the engine without breaking the license that was agreed to. Seems rather restrictive to me. XE is available for free and can be put to use commercially if one wishes. And the prototype to which you refer is a user defined prototype. You might choose, if you wish, to prototype eBay or Amazon.com. Well - not totally true. The OTN Developer License Terms for Oracle Database Express Edition states.. "Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms." and the above quote is from that document. So the way the license is worded, the XE License is more restrictive than the enterprise license because it states that all of the restrictions of the enterprise down load apply to the XE as well. Also not true about the prototype. By wording it to state "single prototype of an application" that means that it does not apply to a system, only to an application. Also, it is only allowable to be used by a single prototype, which legally means that no refinements of the prototype is allowed. That is substantially different from limiting the download to only your current customer base. Again not true. You do not have to be a customer to download. You do have to register, but you do not have to be a customer. It is curious that Informix can be thought of as a peer with Oracle yet, I see no market buzz in the Linux world for Informix like you do for Oracle. In fact, Oracle basically took the Linux market away from anything IBM, and has even tried to say that they were first on Linux, which they clearly were not. What _is_ possible from a marketing perspective for Informix is a huge opportunity that has basically gone wasted. It's almost criminally negligent, but forgivable knowing the retards running the Marketing Dept for Informix. Kind of easy to look the other way when you understand that the product suffers from its own family more than the neighbors. There is a big opportunity right now to make Informix more well known, and the most amazing part of it is that it costs IBM little if anything to make right. Get the developer program going--really going--and make the enterprise version available to developers either for free, or at reduced cost, to allow them to develop with the entire product, not something pared down to appease critics. You will get a bigger harvest, and some market momentum. Get some books out there to help people understand the product, and for crying out loud, pass out some marketing freebies to reward people. A little can go a long way.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - |
#14
| |||
| |||
|
|
You seem to be suggesting that they should ignore this. But, how many of us are sufficiently profesionally and financially independent that we can just ignore the instructions of our bosses? Actually I wish DB2 had the same marketing guys/gals as IDS. |
#15
| |||
| |||
|
|
Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: InDeep wrote: I'm not enraged, just baffled beyond belief that nobody else has even commented or tried to get this fixed. Not intending to be the gadfly but I think rather obviously because is of so little interest no one really much cares. Making something available only to the existing customer base ("enter your IBM ID") is not the way to expand marketshare. This becomes even more poignant when one considers that the primary competitor allows anyone to download theirs for free. No ID required, no marketing questions, no hassles. Well maybe. But according to the license agreement for the down loaded Oracle server, it can only be used to create an initial single prototype of any application. It can not be used for any other purposes. That includes learning about the product, teaching the product to anyone else, patching any prototype, etc. To quote the license agreement that Oracle uses for their download... "LICENSE RIGHTS We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the program only for the purpose of developing a single prototype of your application, and not for any other purpose." Looks like you can't even use the downloaded engine to learn about the engine without breaking the license that was agreed to. Seems rather restrictive to me. XE is available for free and can be put to use commercially if one wishes. And the prototype to which you refer is a user defined prototype. You might choose, if you wish, to prototype eBay or Amazon.com. Well - not totally true. The OTN Developer License Terms for Oracle Database Express Edition states.. "Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms." and the above quote is from that document. So the way the license is worded, the XE License is more restrictive than the enterprise license because it states that all of the restrictions of the enterprise down load apply to the XE as well. Also not true about the prototype. By wording it to state "single prototype of an application" that means that it does not apply to a system, only to an application. Also, it is only allowable to be used by a single prototype, which legally means that no refinements of the prototype is allowed. That is substantially different from limiting the download to only your current customer base. Again not true. You do not have to be a customer to download. You do have to register, but you do not have to be a customer. I don't know what you're reading but here's the reality and the link: http://www.oracle.com/technology/sof...xelinsoft.html License Rights We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the programs for: (a) purposes of developing, prototyping and running your applications for your own internal data processing operations; Meaning you can run it in production. (b) you may also distribute the programs with your applications; Self explanatory (c) you may use the programs to provide third party demonstrations and training; Again self-explanatory and d) you may copy and distribute the programs to your licensees provided that each such licensee agrees to the terms of this Agreement. Again no ambiguity here either. |
#16
| |||
| |||
|
|
DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: InDeep wrote: This becomes even more poignant when one considers that the primary competitor allows anyone to download theirs for free. No ID required, no marketing questions, no hassles. Well maybe. But according to the license agreement for the down loaded Oracle server, it can only be used to create an initial single prototype of any application. It can not be used for any other purposes. That includes learning about the product, teaching the product to anyone else, patching any prototype, etc. XE is available for free and can be put to use commercially if one wishes. And the prototype to which you refer is a user defined prototype. You might choose, if you wish, to prototype eBay or Amazon.com. Well - not totally true. The OTN Developer License Terms for Oracle Database Express Edition states.. "Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms." and the above quote is from that document. So the way the license is worded, the XE License is more restrictive than the enterprise license because it states that all of the restrictions of the enterprise down load apply to the XE as well. Also not true about the prototype. By wording it to state "single prototype of an application" that means that it does not apply to a system, only to an application. Also, it is only allowable to be used by a single prototype, which legally means that no refinements of the prototype is allowed. That is substantially different from limiting the download to only your current customer base. Again not true. You do not have to be a customer to download. You do have to register, but you do not have to be a customer. I don't know what you're reading but here's the reality and the link: http://www.oracle.com/technology/sof...xelinsoft.html License Rights We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the programs for: (a) purposes of developing, prototyping and running your applications for your own internal data processing operations; Meaning you can run it in production. (b) you may also distribute the programs with your applications; Self explanatory (c) you may use the programs to provide third party demonstrations and training; Again self-explanatory and d) you may copy and distribute the programs to your licensees provided that each such licensee agrees to the terms of this Agreement. Again no ambiguity here either. Yes - this is the "OTN License Agreement for Oracle Database Express Edition", and what you are saying would be true if the license was totally self contained. It is not. If you read the entire license and not just a few lines, then you would see... Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms. The OTN License Agreement terms also apply to all updates you receive under your Technology Track subscription. And Oracle Technology Network License Agreement is |
#17
| |||
| |||
|
|
Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: Madison Pruet wrote: DA Morgan wrote: InDeep wrote: This becomes even more poignant when one considers that the primary competitor allows anyone to download theirs for free. No ID required, no marketing questions, no hassles. Well maybe. But according to the license agreement for the down loaded Oracle server, it can only be used to create an initial single prototype of any application. It can not be used for any other purposes. That includes learning about the product, teaching the product to anyone else, patching any prototype, etc. XE is available for free and can be put to use commercially if one wishes. And the prototype to which you refer is a user defined prototype. You might choose, if you wish, to prototype eBay or Amazon.com. Well - not totally true. The OTN Developer License Terms for Oracle Database Express Edition states.. "Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms." and the above quote is from that document. So the way the license is worded, the XE License is more restrictive than the enterprise license because it states that all of the restrictions of the enterprise down load apply to the XE as well. Also not true about the prototype. By wording it to state "single prototype of an application" that means that it does not apply to a system, only to an application. Also, it is only allowable to be used by a single prototype, which legally means that no refinements of the prototype is allowed. That is substantially different from limiting the download to only your current customer base. Again not true. You do not have to be a customer to download. You do have to register, but you do not have to be a customer. I don't know what you're reading but here's the reality and the link: http://www.oracle.com/technology/sof...xelinsoft.html License Rights We grant you a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to use the programs for: (a) purposes of developing, prototyping and running your applications for your own internal data processing operations; Meaning you can run it in production. (b) you may also distribute the programs with your applications; Self explanatory (c) you may use the programs to provide third party demonstrations and training; Again self-explanatory and d) you may copy and distribute the programs to your licensees provided that each such licensee agrees to the terms of this Agreement. Again no ambiguity here either. Yes - this is the "OTN License Agreement for Oracle Database Express Edition", and what you are saying would be true if the license was totally self contained. It is not. If you read the entire license and not just a few lines, then you would see... Note: You are bound by the Oracle Technology Network ("OTN") License Agreement terms. The OTN License Agreement terms also apply to all updates you receive under your Technology Track subscription. And Oracle Technology Network License Agreement is Madison - your are reading this wrong. I wrote the license for XE and it does not 'inherit' restrictions from any other license. You can use XE freely for whatever you want, as long as you stay within the limits of the product - 4 GB of data etc. You can definitely deploy XE in production without charge. You can also distribute it, and teach with it, etc etc. |
#18
| |||
| |||
|
|
"InDeep" <indeep (AT) indeep (DOT) com> wrote in message news:Ck57j.4925$iD5.3228 (AT) fe77 (DOT) usenetserver.com... It is curious that Informix can be thought of as a peer with Oracle yet, I see no market buzz in the Linux world for Informix like you do for Oracle. In fact, Oracle basically took the Linux market away from anything IBM, and has even tried to say that they were first on Linux, which they clearly were not. What _is_ possible from a marketing perspective for Informix is a huge opportunity that has basically gone wasted. It's almost criminally negligent, but forgivable knowing the retards running the Marketing Dept for Informix. Kind of easy to look the other way when you understand that the product suffers from its own family more than the neighbors. As per my previous post, your criticism is misplaced. The people who run Marketing for Informix are *not* retards. They are constrained in what they can do by an over-riding strategy within IBM about the extent to which they can promote Informix. You seem to be suggesting that they should ignore this. But, how many of us are sufficiently profesionally and financially independent that we can just ignore the instructions of our bosses? |
#19
| |||
| |||
|
|
To answer your question, I completely understand your pain, and your needing to sacrifice your values to protect yourself. |
#20
| |||
| |||
|
|
Mark Townsend wrote: Madison - your are reading this wrong. I wrote the license for XE and it does not 'inherit' restrictions from any other license. You can use XE freely for whatever you want, as long as you stay within the limits of the product - 4 GB of data etc. You can definitely deploy XE in production without charge. You can also distribute it, and teach with it, etc etc. Thank you, Mark, for clearing up the apparent misunderstanding. Mark, are you speaking as an Oracle spokesperson here? Just curious. |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
| |